Priority
Normal
Type
Bug 
State
Fixed 
Assignee
Eugene Vigdorchik 
Subsystem
Code Analysis. Dependencies 
Affected versions
Fixed in
Fixed in build
Next build 
Build
4155
Fixed in build
5136
Severity
0
  • Submitted by   Gilles Philippart
    4 years ago (08 Feb 2006 19:59)
  • Updated by   root
    3 weeks ago (17 Jan 2010 19:26)
  • Jira: IDEA-31467
    (history, comments)

IDEA-31467

Lib to module dependency issue

0
DependencyProblem.zip   (12 KB)
Added by <no user>
16 Sep 2009
dependencyproblem-5.1.png   (49 KB)
Added by <no user>
16 Sep 2009
dependencyproblem-5.0.2.png   (50 KB)

I have attached an ipr reproducing this problem.

The A class in this project hasn't any highlight in 5.0.2, but has an highlighted error in 5.1 (4155)

See the screenshots :

in 5.0.2 :


in 5.1


Issue was resolved
Comments (4)
 
History (1)
 
Links
 
Eugene Vigdorchik
  Eugene Vigdorchik
09 Feb 2006 19:47
(4 years ago)
#permalink
We have never encouraged this kind of setup with library to source dependencies.
However for backward compatibility the problem will be fixed in 5.1.1
Gilles Philippart
  Gilles Philippart
10 Feb 2006 18:55
(3 years ago)
#permalink
In fact, when dealing with very large application, this can happen quite often :
Our team is responsible for 2 components : ComponentA and ComponentB. (say about 500 classes each)
Our ComponentA uses our ComponentB (set up as 2 modules in Intellij with a A-> B dependency, and it works great)
And another team developping ComponentC uses ComponentB too. But we don't have access to their source repository directly, instead they "publish" a jar and the corresponding sources on a regular basis...

That's the kind of setup that I reproduced in the attached ipr and with only 1 class per component, but you get the picture...

Gilles
Venkat Sonnathi
  Venkat Sonnathi
16 Feb 2006 06:19
(3 years ago)
#permalink
I agree with Giles. This is a case we are also running into. Please make this change permanent.

Regards,
--Venkat.
Henri Ropponen
  Henri Ropponen
17 Feb 2006 10:34
(3 years ago)
#permalink
We have a similar case. I would like to add that this error also prevents one from using the "smart" functions like SHIFT + SPACE etc. and listing usages.

BR,
Henri